
Author: Paul Brennan
I have a lot of respect for martial artists and martial arts in general not least because I have been involved with martial arts most of my adult life. However, I also have many years of operational and training experience in both the military and the police and I have been aware for some time that there is a disconnect between the two approaches to combat training which may help to explain why despite appearing to be perfect bedfellows, martial arts has never really caught on with either the military or the police.
My first realisation of this conflict occurred when a fellow police officer I was training asked me one day how many techniques I knew. “Hundreds” I answered “but ask me how many I use”. I didn’t even have to stop and think “five” I said…”and each one was for a different tactical problem!”. Even though I occasionally used some of those other techniques operationally, it was generally when I was the one in control and I was simply using the subject as a training opportunity. I knew from experience that for those more stressful moments when I was under real pressure I would invariably revert back to my trusty toolkit of battle proven techniques.
An art by definition is a thing of beauty which is normally produced by an artist after many years of training and practice. Unfortunately there is no beauty in violence; nor may there be sufficient time for a prospective artist to learn the skills they need effectively before they have to face their moment of truth. To survive most people do not need an art they need a science.
There are 3 key factors that differentiate CQC from martial arts: focus, teaching methodology and time. Martial arts is very much technique focussed whereas martial science is more strategy focussed. This strategic approach is crucial as it clearly identifies and maintains focus on what needs to be achieved. The strategy then determines the tactics with each tactical problem requiring a tactical response. Then and only then should techniques be considered. This must be based on simplicity, effectiveness, broad range of application and an understanding of the key underpinning principles. Understanding those principles allows the operator to adapt under pressure.
It is human nature to want to complicate a process and to assume that the acquisition of techniques is a benchmark of competency and progress. Combatives takes the opposite view. As Einstein is reputed to have said…”make it as simple as possible, but no simpler”. For a technique to become part of the CQC syllabus it must either replace an existing technique (because it is more effective) or it must address a tactical problem for which there is no current solution. It is worth mentioning that there are many highly competent street fighters who also apply Einstein’s principle. They call their approach the sucker punch! With martial science less is more!
This strategic focus is supported by a teaching strategy which is based on operational experience, a deep understanding of the physiology of the stress response and educational psychology. Martial arts uses some very effective methods for training based primarily on skills repetition and practice. This approach undoubtedly works but it takes a lot of time and effort to fully habitualise those responses. It is also worth pointing out that those responses need to be appropriate for the context in which they will be applied. Real world violence is a far different experience than the sports arena or the dojo where more stylised martial arts forms of attack may be practiced. The scientific approach conditions the appropriate responses using drills which progressively develop students and ultimately recreates as closely as possible the context in which they will be applied. Students are trained to respond at both the cognitive (judgemental) and unconscious (instinctive) levels using operant conditioning methods. Experience is key…but it must be the right experience.
This more scientific based system and the battle proven method used to teach those skills vastly reduces training time. A good example of this occurred during World War 2 when Japanese interrogators forced captured Z force commando’s to fight their martial arts trained captors. In the words of a Japanese kempeitai officer who was an experienced jiu jitsu black belt. “I am astonished that you are all so good after such a short study during your war training of what is a difficult Japanese martial art”. The commando unarmed combat training syllabus during WW2 typically lasted for only 8 hours!
©Paul Brennan 2015